26.11.26 | AIxIA Spotlight Seminar: Debating AI – Alternatives for Post-hoc Debate Judgement

Date: 26 November 2026
Time: 17:00 CET
Location: Online | YouTube
Organiser: AIxIA – Italian Association for Artificial Intelligence
Speaker: Prof. Francesca Toni, Imperial College London

The Italian Association for Artificial Intelligence (AIxIA), a CAIRNE Gold Member and host of CAIRNE’s Rome office, invites the AI research community to its next Spotlight Seminar on AI, featuring Prof. Francesca Toni from Imperial College London.

About the Seminar

Debating AI: Alternatives for Post-hoc Debate Judgement

Debates are increasingly being used in agentic AI systems to improve performance, explainability, and user engagement. However, determining the outcomes of these debates often relies on external judges, including large language models (LLMs).

In this seminar, Prof. Francesca Toni will present a novel theoretical framework for evaluating debates between AI agents, focusing on key properties such as reproducibility, robustness, groundedness, and explainability.

The presentation will compare two approaches to debate judgement: LLM-based evaluation and formal semantics derived from computational argumentation. While both approaches demonstrate comparable accuracy, argumentation-based methods offer formal guarantees that LLM-based judges may lack.

The seminar will highlight the potential of computational argumentation as a principled foundation for evaluating debates in AI systems.

The presentation is primarily based on the research paper A Theory of Post-hoc Debate Judgement.

About the Speaker

Prof. Francesca Toni is Professor in Computational Logic at Imperial College London, where she leads the Computational Logic and Argumentation (CLArg) research group and co-directs the Centre for eXplainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI).

Her research focuses on knowledge representation and reasoning, computational argumentation, multi-agent systems, and explainable AI. She is a Fellow of EurAI and AAAI and has received an ERC Advanced Grant for her research on argumentation-based interactive explanations.

About the AIxIA Spotlight Seminars

Organised by AIxIA, the Spotlight Seminars on AI series brings together leading researchers to explore current scientific challenges, emerging trends, and developments across artificial intelligence.

The seminars are aimed at a broad audience interested in AI research, with particular encouragement for PhD students and early-career researchers to participate.

Participation

The seminar will take place online on 26 November 2026 at 17:00 CET, streamed via AIxIA’s YouTube channel.

Watch live on AIxIA’s YouTube channel

The recording will remain available on the channel following the event.

The recording will remain available on the channel following the event.

.